http://www.norcoworldwide.com - $20 discount for VIP's



Other Related Topics >> Laws, Regulations, and Enforcement

Pages: 1
dkushner99
Newbie


Reged: 12/31/02
Posts: 47
Loc: San Jose, CA
Is my back surgeon liable for malpractice?
      #82219 - 06/12/03 07:56 PM

Does anyone know what constitutes malpractice? Sorry for the longwinded story ...
Let me explain my situation. About 1 1/2 years ago I suddenly lost control of my left foot. I could not walk normally because of this. It turns out that I had "foot drop" which was caused by a buldging disk in my back pinching a nerve that controls my foot. This was diagnosed and I was scheduled for surgery. The surgeon performed L4/5 back surgery and removed about 3/4 of the disk. After 3 months the surgeon took me off vicodin and put me on motrin. He said the pain should eventually go away. After 2-3 months of being in pain (on motrin) I went back to complain that the pain was not going away and the motrin was not working. Over several months, the surgeon had me try several non-addictive pain meds, none seemed to work. We also tried cortazone which did work, but only worked for 1-2 weeks then wore off. Finally, he put me back on Norco and referred me to a pain management specialist.

After 4 weeks the the pain management specialist finally saw me and recomended tramadol. I said that I would rather take norco because I knew that it worked for me. She insisted that I try the tramadol and said that if it didn't work for me she would put me back on norco. After a few days on tramadol, I called her and told her that the tramadol helped, but I was still in pain and it sometimes gave me headaches. She made another appointment and gave me one RX for Norco and said that I would have to get refills from my primary care doctor and that she would contact him and that I should make an appointment with him.
She charged me over 600 bucks for this and as it turns out my insurance did not cover it. Her assistant had told me that I would be covered for this. I did nogotiate a fair paymet with them ... Anyway, I made an appointment with my primary care doctor and when I got there she had not contacted him at all. I explained the situation to him and he gave me a prescription for several months.

(By the way, About 5 months after the surgery I started regaining my foot! My foot is fine now, but I have been in pain since the surgery! I had no pain before the surgery.) My primary care doctor didn't want to prescribe norco forever so I started getting it from DB.

Today something very starange happened. I stood up at work and I could not walk. I had lost the control of my foot again. I sat down and in a few minutes my foot started working again. I called the surgeion right away and he saw me that evening. After I explained what had happened, he said I probably just had the circulation cut off temprarily. I told him that this was different because if my foot "fell asleep" I could still move it. He looked at me like I was lying or something. I asked hime what if it happens again ... he said he could give me a shot for inflamation (Strange .. if my foot fell asleep, why give me a shot for inflamation!?!)

He also asked me what meds I was taking and I told hme that my primary care Dr. was giving me Norco but I am now only taking tramadol (which is true, I get norco from DB now.) I don't know why he asked this, I didn't come in for pain and I did not ask him for pain meds. I also told hime that I was scheduled at a UCSF to hopefully undergo treatment for to remove the scar tissue at the surgical site that is probably causing the pain.

It seems to me that he has done everything NOT TO TREAT MY PAIN, and now I finally think I've figured out why. He does not want to admit liability!!! I'm wondering if I have a case for malpractice. Whan I first saw this guy he never mentioned that fact that I might be in permanent pain after the surgery. I never thaught of it because I was not in pain before the surgery. He only mentioned the slight possiblity od HIV or Hep if I lost blood during the surgery. He also mentioned that I may not regain use of my foot. That's it.

Can I sue this guy because I now have chronic pain due to his surgery?

Thanks,
- Daniel




Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
scissorhands
Member


Reged: 06/04/03
Posts: 167
Loc: Hell
Re: Is my back surgeon liable for malpractice? [Re: dkushner99]
      #82237 - 06/12/03 11:12 PM

Daniel:
Not sure if you have a case or not, I do know that after having four back surgeries(one of then they left a pair of scisssors in my back and had to go back and have them removed) my neuro always went into great details when explaining what complications could happen. I was never guaranteed anything...Nothing is what I ended up with. I think you have about a year after any accident or surgery to file a claim and after that its just your word against his...Sorry to hear you are having so much trouble, Changing doctors is sometimes a solution.

scissorhands

--------------------
Baseball is wrong...Man with four balls cannot walk!


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
potatoboy99
Permanent Fixture


Reged: 02/04/03
Posts: 1199
Loc: Deep North (East)
Re: Is my back surgeon liable for malpractice? [Re: dkushner99]
      #82238 - 06/12/03 11:12 PM

Quote:

My primary care doctor didn't want to prescribe norco forever so I started getting it from DB.





This is going to sound incredibly insensitive and pedantic but unless I'm missing something around here you are not getting your norco from DB!

That said, I'm very sorry to hear about what you are going through post-op. Wow what a drag. The possibility that your surgery could result in chronic pain should certainly have been make clear to you. It's very difficult to know the right questions to ask to make informed decisions in situations like this. I was scheduled last year for surgery to remove the excess tissue in my eshophagus that apparently causes my snoring and sleep apnea, which makes it almost impossible to get a good nights sleep. I thought i had asked all the right questions as regards the risks of this surgery, when almost as an afterthought the surgeon let it slip that 10 percent of those undergoing this procedure permanently lose the abillity to speak! Those odds aren't good enough for me. (I have a scary hernia operation story but I'll post it someplace else).

Sorry I can't advise on wether you can sue your doc. Wether or not he is incompetent, it sure sounds like he could take lessons in communication skills.

Good luck wth everything...


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Daycamp72
Enthusiast


Reged: 06/29/02
Posts: 283
Loc: Tara
Re: Is my back surgeon liable for malpractice? [Re: dkushner99]
      #82254 - 06/13/03 03:02 AM

99, it's really difficult to sue a doc.
I had nine surgeries last year for breast cancer reconstruction and everything that COULD have gone wrong, WENT wrong. Unfortunately, I have a little ways to go to finish up. I DO think that it is less difficult to sue physicians in some states. Wonder how we could find that info?
If my plastic surgeon is NOT a candidate for a law suit then NO doctor is! I won't bore you all with all the details of the surgeries (plus the MRSA (staph) infection, but it was hell on earth.
Now, they won't return my telephone calls!
Good luck.


Post Extras: Print Post   Remind Me!   Notify Moderator  
Pages: 1



Extra information
4 registered and 5 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  Heidi, Melody 

Print Topic

Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is enabled
      UBBCode is enabled

Rating:
Topic views: 443

Rate this topic

Jump to

Help & Contact Information | Privacy statement | Rules Free Members Area

*
UBB.threads™ 6.5
With Modifications from ThreadsDev.com by Joshua Pettit