Pharmacy List: US List · International List · Canadian List · Black List | Drug List · Compare Prices
Recent Posts: Past 24 Hours · Past 48 Hours · Past Week
This study compares gender differences in the efficacy of two kinds of morphine-based meds for acute pain.
Women tend to respond better to kappa-based agonists and men to mu-based agonists; the implication being that the site of analgesic response differs between females and males.
Feb. 17, 2004 For acute pain management, women respond better to a kappa agonist than to a mu agonist, according to the results of a randomized, double-blind trial published in the January issue of the Southern Medical Journal.
"Two commonly used opioid analgesics for uncomplicated patients are morphine sulfate and butorphanol," write Penny L. Miller, MS, FNP, and Amy A. Ernst, MD, FACEP, from the University of California, Davis Medical Center, in Sacramento. "Preliminary studies suggest that there may be a sex difference in response to the site of action of these two medications."
The objective of this trial was to evaluate whether there is a sex difference in the analgesic response to the prototypical mu-receptor agonist, morphine sulfate, compared with the prototypical kappa agonist, butorphanol, in the emergency department.
Of 94 patients with acute moderate to severe traumatic pain of injury who were enrolled in this study, 49 (52%) were men and 45 (48%) were women. Subjects were randomized to receive morphine or butorphanol. Both groups were similar in demographics.
At 60 minutes, women had significantly lower visual analog scale (VAS) scores with butorphanol than with morphine (P = .046). There was a nonsignificant trend suggesting that men responded better to morphine than women did (P = .06). At 30 minutes, diastolic blood pressures were lower in women than in men.
Study limitations include use of patient self-report of pain.
"Females had better pain scores with butorphanol than morphine at 60 minutes," the authors write. "Kappa receptor agonists should be chosen preferentially for female patients with acute traumatic injury pain."
South Med J. 2004;97:35-41
-------------------- how can you tell the Dreamer from the one who dreams the dream?
This finding has been published since at least 1996:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=8898754&dopt=Abstract
Clinical information aside, given the difference in the biological "division of labor" among men and women, I have absolutely NO problem proclaiming from the highest pulpit that women are the pain tolerance champs compared to men.
Besides, I can't think of anything good that might come from contending otherwise.
'Tis often wiser to be thought a fool than to open one's mouth and remove all doubt. -- Anonymous
Previous
Index
Next
Threaded
Edit 
Reply 
Quote 
