 |
antique
Banned
Reged: 09/01/03
Posts: 215
Loc: east coast
|
|
I started writing this message as a reply in another thread "cyclobarbitol" then I changed my mind and decided to start a new thread with it. I'm probably going to get flamed for it for being oversimplified or way too basic for the people on this board or whatever, but I'm going to put it here anyway because it may help someone to avoid damaging their health. I invite anyone to correct me where I'm wrong or to explain things more clearly than I do. In fact, I would appreciate it.
I think that most people are aware that acetominophen (APAP) can damage your liver if you take too much of it. There have been some great threads here with advice on supplements to take to minimize or avoid the damage. Also, great advice on having your liver functioning tested periodically if you are taking APAP on a regular basis. What I don't think that many people realize is that it does not necessarily take a lot of APAP to cause damage.
People's body chemistries are SO different. Besides any potential allergies to a med, there are different rates of absorption into the blood stream, different amounts of enzymes that assist in metabolizing the meds, differences in receptor sites, and so on.
The reason APAP is toxic to the liver when you take an amount that is above the limit as noted, say on a bottle of Tylenol, is that the APAP is metabolized with the aid of certain enzymes to form chemicals that are useful for pain relief but that are not terribly harmful to your body. There are a limited amount of those enzymes in your body. If you take more APAP at one time than you have of those enzymes needed to metabolize it, the excess APAP gets metabolized in a different way to form chemicals that are toxic to the liver - very toxic to the liver even in small amounts.
For some people who have less than an average amount of those enzymes taking even the recommended dose of APAP can be too much and can cause damage to the liver. For the people with a larger than average amount of those enzymes taking over the recommended maximum dose causes no harm to them.
For the average person it actually does not take much more APAP than the maximum recommended dose to cause damage to the liver. I don't think that most people realize this. That's one reason I'm picking on APAP.
Another reason I'm picking on APAP is that it is in a lot of the pain meds we use. It is in so many different OTC remedies that you can end up taking too much without realizing it. A good example is when you have a cold and you take some Tylenol and some cough syrup. Some of the cough syrups have acetominophen, so if you take 2 Tylenols and a dose of the cough syrup, you have taken over the maximum recommended dose. Plus you probably won't know that you have killed off part of your liver until you have killed off enough of it that it noticeably impacts your health. If you take even a little too much (too much depends on your own personal body chemistry), then that little amount that doesn't get metabolized in the desirable way, gets metabolized into the toxic chemicals, and the small amount of toxic chemicals kill off a few liver cells. If this happens on a regular basis, you will eventually destroy the entire liver. Liver cells don't regenerate.
I'm not a doctor, and I hope I don't come across as preachy or condescending for giving a simplified explanation. Don't aim to scare anybody either, but please be careful. You can't always tell that you are damaging your body until it's too late or at least really bad. So don't be flippant about taking a little more than the recommended maximum dose.
The rate of absorption can vary a lot between people too. As well, the rate of absorption can vary a lot in one person depending on a number of factors including what other meds they have taken and whether they just ate. For one person taking a medication, the medication might slowly enter the bloodstream, so the liver gets a little bit at a time and there is not too much medication at any one time for the enzymes to metabolize. For another person, the same medication could immediately absorb into the bloodstream so that it all arrives at the liver at the same time.
So don't assume that because a person of a particular size or weight took some amount of a medication and didn't appear to be harmed by it that someone else of the same size or weight could take the same amount of that med and die or be seriously harmed by it. Also, this applies to anything you ingest and not just medications. Good, clean water is toxic if you get too much of it in you at one time.
|
zorg
Veteran
Reged: 04/29/02
Posts: 559
Loc: Midwest
|
|
You'll get no argument from me, I agree with all viewpoints that address the difference in action and chemistry in each person. To go even further, I would suggest that there are tremendous differences within the same person, but at different hours in the day, or different moods in the same person, etc. Every point of dosage is a completely unique snapshot in time, and all actions beyond that are dependent on the very unique set of variables per person, per day, per minute, per mood, per weather, per state of mind, etc.
This is the only way to explain the range of action of the same medication in different people at different times... in my opinion. I personally have had wildly varying reactions to some medications in the same dosages with EVERY other control variable IDENTICAL.
Good post my friend 
|
yawkaw3
Pooh-Bah

Reged: 03/22/03
Posts: 1193
|
|
Excellent post, antique. I also wanted to add that alcohol plays a dynamic as well; you dramatically decrease your liver's ability to detoxify APAP when you're drinking. Cocaine as well (which I would assume you are using for its legit medical use as a topically applied local anesthetic). Plenty of other drugs also, so it's really something you have to watch out for, please tread carefully.
-yawkaw
|
wat853son
Member
Reged: 04/28/03
Posts: 150
Loc: USA
|
|
I also shall over-simplify and quote the master.
All things are poison and nothing is without poison. It is the dose that makes a thing poisonous.
- Paracelsus
Almost 500 years ago Paracelsus (1493-1541) wrote: "Dosis facit venenum." ("The dose makes the poison."). The relationship between dose and response (effect) is still one of the most fundamental concepts of toxicology.
|
antique
Banned
Reged: 09/01/03
Posts: 215
Loc: east coast
|
|
Thank you, sonick, yawkaw, and herbandseal for the extra clarifications. I'll add one more myself that I'm not sure I got across in the first post.
The therapeutic dose of some meds like APAP are not that much different than a toxic dose. The therapeutic dose is the amount of the med that usually needs to be taken to get the desired effects of the med (and that is determined for an average population without necessarily taking into account individual differences in body chemistries). For some meds, the dose at which the med starts to become toxic in the average person is way above that therapeutic dose. For other meds, even a tiny amount above the therapeutic dose can be toxic. Another good example of a med that has an EXTREMELY small difference between its therapeutic dose and toxic dose is lithium. People who are being given lithium are monitored very carefully by testing the amount of med in their blood stream on a regular basis. And the dosage is increased by very small increments to get to a therapeutic dose.
APAP concerns me because its toxic dose is not much higher than its therapeutic dose and I don't think that many of the people taking it are monitored to see if they are getting too much. Certainly, people who are just taking it in OTC remedies are not being monitored unless there is coincidentally some other reason they are being monitored.
Like sonick, I have had a personal experience with taking a normal dose of a med at one time without any bad effects and then taking the same med, same dose another time and having a very bad reaction. And it was not due to any obvious reason like a drug interaction.
And again, please, I'm not trying to scare anyone. I just hope that this post will make people more careful and observant about what they are taking and how much. To some extent it is a Best if kept off the board shoot too because you can be careful and still end up with a problem. There is always some risk involved in taking any med, eating any food, or living life in general.
I really, really like the serenity prayer, and you certainly don't have to be religious to appreciate the wisdom of it. If I didn't know better, I would think that someone was observing me living my life and wrote this as a message to me. 
God grant me the serenity
to accept the things I cannot change;
courage to change the things I can;
and wisdom to know the difference.
|
antique
Banned
Reged: 09/01/03
Posts: 215
Loc: east coast
|
|
I posted some info from websites on this topic in another forum, so I have copied that post to put here.
There are some good websites that discuss the APAP issue & I'll post some links here:
http://www.tylenol.com/products/adult/detail.jhtml?id=tylenol/products/adult/regularextra.inc
Let's start with Tylenol's website - not that it is the most straightforward place to get this info! If you put together the info in the table "take 2 tablets every 4 to 6 hours as needed" and "do not take more than 12 tablets in 24 hours" for the regular strength Tylenol with the info on the dose of acetominophen in regular strength Tylenol - 325mg per tablet, then you get (do not take more than 3900mg in 24 hours). One thing that they should stress here is that you also should not take more than 750mg in any 4 to 6 hour period. BUT for some people, 750mg taken in a 4 to 6 hour period is too much (even if they have not had alcohol). BTW, these were adult doses.
http://www.carefulparents.com/tylenol.htm
This site addresses the dangers of tylenol in children, but the same concepts apply to adults. For the parents of young children out there, I recommend bookmarking this website to consult for all kinds of safety info regarding children. It has some links to other useful websites as well.
http://www.medicinenet.com/Tylenol_Liver_Damage/page1.htm
This website has a lot of info including explanations about how APAP is metabolized and how it can become toxic AND signs of APAP poisoning and what to do. You may want to bookmark this one for future reference. I don't agree with the position they take that usual doses of APAP rarely cause significant liver damage. There is no such thing as insignificant liver damage! The liver cannot regenerate, so any damage it suffers is cumulative. If you take pain killers with APAP regularly, like many of us do, then every little bit of damage will eventually add up to significant damage given enough time. Also, I take issue with them saving up for a little blurb at the end that even doses that are not much larger than the max recommended doses can cause serious injury or death in some people. This website is worth a read though. If you don't want to read that website, then just have a look at this paragraph from it:
"How does an overdose of acetaminophen cause liver injury?
The answer is that liver damage from acetaminophen occurs when the glutathione pathway is overwhelmed by too much of acetaminophen's metabolite, NAPQI. Then, this toxic compound accumulates in the liver and causes the damage. Furthermore, alcohol and certain medications such as phenobarbital, phenytoin, or carbamezepine (anti-seizure medications) or isoniazid (anti-TB drug) can significantly increase the damage. They do this by making the cytochrome P-450 system in the liver more active. This increased P-450 activity, as you might expect, results in an increased formation of NAPQI from the acetaminophen. Additionally, chronic alcohol use, as well as the fasting state or poor nutrition, can each deplete the liver's glutathione. So, alcohol both increases the toxic compound and decreases the detoxifying material. Accordingly, the bottom line in an acetaminophen overdose is that when the amount of NAPQI is too much for the available glutathione to detoxify, liver damage occurs."
http://www.canoe.ca/Health0103/26_pain-ap.html
This website so aptly says what I have been trying to get across that I'm going to paste the article here:
Acetaminophen overdose worries
By LAURAN NEERGAARD -- The Associated Press
WASHINGTON -- Evidence that many North Americans may poison their livers by unwittingly taking toxic doses of acetaminophen has the U.S. government considering if consumers need stiffer warnings about the popular over-the-counter painkiller.
It's not the first time acetaminophen, best known by the Tylenol brand, has drawn concern. There are warnings not to take it if you consume more than three alcoholic drinks, because the combination can poison your liver.
But the latest worry is about overdoses: taking too much for too long, or mixing the myriad acetaminophen-containing headache, cold/flu and other remedies, or just popping extra pills.
Because acetaminophen is nonprescription, people think "it must be safe and they take it like M&Ms," says Dr. William Lee of the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas.
Lee's data suggest acetaminophen overdoses could be a bigger cause of liver failure than some prescription drugs recently banned for liver poisoning, such as the diabetes medicine Rezulin.
He tracked more than 300 acute liver failure cases at 22 hospitals and linked 38 per cent to acetaminophen, versus 18 per cent of cases caused by other medications. In a second database tracking 307 adults with severe liver injury -- not full-fledged failure -- at six hospitals, Lee linked acetaminophen to 35 per cent of cases.
Most were accidents and should have been preventable, Lee contends.
The findings surprised Food and Drug Administration officials, who this month began investigating how big a risk the painkiller poses and whether more explicit warnings are needed. They are even seeking data from Britain, where so many people used acetaminophen for suicide that British health authorities now restrict how many tablets are sold at once.
Acetaminophen's liver toxicity "is conspicuous in its magnitude compared to some of the other bad players we've taken off the market," says Dr. Peter Honig, FDA's postmarketing drug safety chief. "We're looking at the data to decide if something has to be done, and what."
Certainly millions of Americans safely take acetaminophen every day. Tylenol maker McNeil Consumer Healthcare calls it one of the safest over-the-counter products and insists liver failure occurs only with substantial overdoses.
"This is not a casual, 'Oops, I took an extra pill,'" stresses McNeil vice-president Dr. Anthony Temple.
And McNeil warns that mixing up doses of infant Tylenol drops with children's Tylenol liquid kills -- the two are not interchangeable. Yet poisonings still occur when parents mix up products and give babies a potentially deadly teaspoon-full instead of a safe dropper-full.
For adults, acetaminophen bottles recommend no more than eight extra-strength pills in 24 hours, and to seek help for overdoses.
Critics want labels to mention liver failure explicitly, saying consumers don't realize overdosing is easy and dangerous.
On the other hand, some FDA officials worry that too-explicit warnings could alert potential suicides to the worst doses, causing a problem such as Britain faced.
To be safe, Lee advises limiting daily acetaminophen to the amount in four extra-strength pills, 2 grams total from all medicines.
Overdoses can be treated easily if doctors know the culprit in time. But initial symptoms are flu-like and doctors may not promptly test for acetaminophen's hallmark sky-high liver enzymes.
|
|
|
 |