I don't know...... I'm thinking about this..... and thinking....

Now, if this poster want's to claim that they received the wrong meds, instead of just throwing them away, wouldn't it make your claim more believable to take out the real meds, and replace them with Tylenol, then send them back that way?

Saying that they threw them away is weird.

If it were me, and I wanted to get something for free, I think I would empty out the meds and replace them with Tylenol, and then say SURE, I'll send them back.

I do think it was a big mistake to throw away the bottles. Then again, if it were me, and I opened up my package and seen that they were the wrong meds, the first thing I would do is call them and tell them about the mistake, not just trash them.

The only thing I can think of out of all this, is that maybe this poster saw that it was Tylenol in the bottle, and tried to contact the OP, and just like others said here that the mail box is always full, and can never get thru to anyone there, then the poster got frustrated and just threw them away figuring that they got scr*wed and thought that they would kiss their mula goodby.
But then finally did get ahold of someone there, but by then it was too late they had already thrown the bottles away, and instead of telling the guy that, decided to let him believe that they were still in possession of the bottles.

Cause why else would you throw them away? If you wanted to make a claim that you received the wrong meds, why not just empty out the bottles and put in the Tylenol, then you would have your own eveidence to send back to them?

That's the only thing I can think of.

Maybe this poster is telling the truth.

Yet, then again, it just goes again...... Stick with the good record OP's. Their reputation stands better.

Oh.... again, another 2cent'er